#TechThursday – Losing Control

  Lindsey Schutters


Physical Buttons in Electric Vehicles

Car manufacturers are waging war on knobs, handles and buttons, and Lindsey Schutters won’t stand for it.

It was the middle of a varsity Quake tournament where I first noticed that the virtual world dulls our senses. Another player kept respawning as either “TST” or “SML,” he later explained that those are the two things you can’t do to him in the game. Technically you can’t touch opposing players in a game either. Computers really don’t like to be touched and carmakers know this.

Even the sensible Swedes fell foul of the anti-tactile tactics when Volvo inexplicably hid the climate controls in the Sensus screen on the otherwise excellent XC90 and every new model since. I didn’t want to believe that Land Rover would pull that trick on its generally tech-challenged vehicles, but the Range Rover Velar kicked off the future vision of button removal that extends to the forthcoming Land Rover Defender – itself a long-standing middle finger to the onward march of technological innovation.

But there is hope and it comes in a painfully flawed package. Honda is renowned for producing challenging digital user interfaces and produced its Sistine Chapel of complex screens in the Honda E electric car. Early reviews coming out of last week’s international launch in Spain paint a scene of overindulgent displays, but also detail the generous use of physical buttons.

Actual buttons in an EV! What sorcery is this?

Actual switchgear isn’t a common sight in futuristic EVs and is in keeping with the E’s retro styling. It’s like the Honda engineers spent a weekend spotting CTIs in the Cape Town CBD and immediately got to work on a concept. And that concept proved to be light on battery capacity and driving range, but heavy on UI navigation flexibility.

Buttons are great for reaching out and touching while keeping your eyes on the road. You learn the layout of your car and bonus points for dials and knobs with haptic response as you adjust a setting. The killer feature of the iPhone, for instance, is the physical mute switch. There’s a simple beauty in a tactile control that can’t be comprehended until its gone.

Computers don’t like to be touched and that creates a critical distance between humans and machines. Buttons bridge that divide, allowing our analogous existence to merge with our digital avatars. There’s power in the press and we can’t let that human touch be taken from us.

 You Might Also Be Interested In

11 Mar, 2020
Four Cars I Thought Were Cool And One I Wish I Understood Better
Kelly Lodewyks harks back to her formative car years and reflects with just a bit of embarrassment.
30 Jan, 2020
#TechThursday – Losing Control
Car manufacturers are waging war on knobs, handles and buttons, and Lindsey Schutters won’t stand for it.
3 Sep, 2019
Thursday News Roundup 2019 #36 - Your News Wrap Up For The Week
We've trawled the internet for the latest motoring news so that you don't need to. Enjoy!
3 May, 2019
Top Five Under Four (Grand Per Month)
Sure, you can save money buying used, but sometimes you just want something straight out of the box and all the benefits of that - a full maintenance and service plan, for example. After spending some time behind the wheel of the new Honda Amaze, itself an affordable compact sedan, Kelly Lodewyks gives her top 5 cars priced under R4 000 per month.
1 Mar, 2019
Honda Amaze Review
The entry-level compact sedan: Does what it says on the tin; offer affordable, hopefully reliable motoring, with space for five and ample boot space to, er, boot. Not exactly exciting. But there is charm to be found, if not performance from the purveyors of Type R and NSX hoonery, says Kelly Lodewyks of the new Honda Amaze.
10 Oct, 2018
Carshop First Drive: New Honda Amaze
The Honda Brio is dead! Due to be discontinued soon, the Brio will be replace by the Honda Amaze, and Juliet McGuire has driven it in Cape Town. Powered by a fuel efficient 1.2-litre (66kW/110Nm) and paired with either manual or automatic (CVT) transmissions, the Amaze is sure to be hit amongst the budget-conscious and fleet owners alike.

Find the keys to your dream
Honda Ballade

2021 1.5 RS CVT

R 389,900

2021 1.2 Trend

R 179,900

2021 1.5 Elegance CVT

R 339,900

2016 1.5 Elegance CVT

R 169,990

2021 1.5 RS CVT

R 369,900

2018 1.5 Executive CVT

R 229,900

All content © Carshop.co.za 2021